Thursday, February 05, 2009

OUR SPINNING PRESIDENT PARSES THE TRUTH

Attorneys are advocates. Senators are deliberators. Neither are leaders. Unfortunately for America, it appears that our new President is little more than a former Senator, formally educated in the law. He is beginning to model the old saw that "lawyers are liars" since they spin and parse the truth in order to win their cases.

Far, far too many of our politicians are trained in the law, ostensibly to practice law as an attorney. Interestingly, however, their intent is almost always to get into politics where their training for tap dancing around the truth can be both a powerful and enriching aphrodisiac. By his announcement earlier today, reported in the article that follows, Barack Obama proves that to date he is little more than an advocate pretending to be a leader.

What he is pushing relative to the 'Stimulus' package now before the Senate is no more than spin. Claiming that if it is not immediately passed into law will plunge the nation into irreversible recession is a flat lie. Of course, he implies that such an outcome will be the case, he does not openly state it. He parses his comments using such modifiers as "could", "might" and "will approach" so that he has cover should none of what he has to say come to pass. On the other hand, if any of it does happen, he can claim to have issued warnings.

Leaders do not try to play both sides of the street. Leaders have the moral courage and integrity to take a stand and promote it. Leaders do not parse, spin and play games with language. Leaders understand that they can be wrong but they make decisions based upon the best information at hand and move forward with confidence and positive energy.

Here is the truth: the 'Stimulus' bill will neither save nor destroy the American economy. In fact, it has very little to do with stimulating the economy, and far more to do with a government spending program. It is, at it's core, a massive payoff for liberal causes denied for decades, written by a liberal Congress and pushed by a liberal attorney President. At best it will hold off economic recovery, at worst it will deepen this recession.

The only force powerful enough to turn our economy around is our economy itself. Thus the only way government can stimulate that same economy is to push policy and spending forward that will immediately improve economic activity. The vast majority of what is in the existing 'Stimulus' legislation does nothing to gain that end. It is a Trojan horse, a fake and a politically motivated give away.

By using fear to drive the public to support for this bill, Obama is a false prophet. He spins like a lawyer as he attempts to influence the 'jury' of public opinion that passing a payoff is good government. Such is not leadership, it is partisanship.

The emperor has no clothes.


Obama warns of need for stimulus bill right away
By DAVID ESPO, AP Special Correspondent

WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama warned on Thursday that failure to act on an economic recovery package could plunge the nation into a long-lasting recession that might prove irreversible, a fresh call to a recalcitrant Congress to move quickly.
In an op-ed piece in The Washington Post, the president argued that each day without his stimulus package, Americans lose more jobs, savings and homes. His message came as congressional leaders struggle to control the huge stimulus bill that's been growing larger by the day in the Senate. The addition of a new tax break for home buyers Wednesday evening sent the price tag well past $900 billion.
Senate Democratic leaders hope for passage of the legislation by Friday at the latest, although prospects appear to hinge on crafting a series of spending reductions that would make the bill more palatable to centrists in both parties.
Obama painted a bleak picture if lawmakers do nothing.
"This recession might linger for years. Our economy will lose 5 million more jobs. Unemployment will approach double digits. Our nation will sink deeper into a crisis that, at some point, we may not be able to reverse," Obama wrote in the newspaper piece titled, "The Action Americans Need."
He rejected the argument that more tax cuts are needed in the plan and that piecemeal measures would be sufficient, arguing that Americans made their intentions clear in the election.
"I reject these theories, and so did the American people when they went to the polls in November and voted resoundingly for change," he wrote.
His latest plea came on the same day the economy dealt with another dose of bad news: A massive jump in jobless claims and another round of weak retail sales.
Initial jobless claims rose to 626,000, a 26-year high, the Labor Department said. And the number of claims by people continuing to apply for unemployment benefits reached a new record of nearly 4.8 million.
The housing tax break was the most notable attempt to date to add help for the crippled industry and gave Republicans a victory as they work to remake the legislation more to their liking.
"It is time to fix housing first," Sen. Johnny Isakson, R-Ga., said Wednesday night as the Senate agreed without controversy to add the new tax break to the stimulus measure, at an estimated cost of nearly $19 billion.
Three swing-vote senators met with Obama at the White House on Wednesday to discuss possible cutbacks, but they declined to discuss details of their talks. Obama has made the legislation a cornerstone of his recovery plan.
For their part, Senate Republicans signaled they would persist in their efforts to reduce spending in the measure, to add tax cuts and reduce the cost of mortgages for millions of homeowners.
Officials figures were unavailable, but it appeared that the measure carried a price tag of more than $920 billion, making it bigger than the financial industry bailout that passed last year and as large as any measure in memory.
Despite bipartisan concerns about the cost, Republicans failed in a series of attempts on Wednesday to cut back the bill's size.
The most sweeping proposal, advanced by Sen. Jim DeMint, R-S.C., would have eliminated all the spending and replaced it with a series of tax cuts. It was defeated 61-36.
Democrats also upheld a so-called Buy American provision that requires projects financed by the measure to be built with domestically produced iron and steel.
But with Obama voicing concern about the provision, the requirement was changed to specify that U.S. international trade agreements not to be violated.
Additionally, Democrats turned back an attempt to strip out a provision that Obama has said was essential. It would provide a tax cut of up to $1,000 for working couples, including those who do not make enough to pay income taxes.
Isakson said the new tax break for home buyers was intended to help revive the housing industry, which has virtually collapsed in the wake of a credit crisis that began last fall.
The proposal would allow a tax credit of 10 percent of the value of new or existing residences, up to a $15,000 limit. Current law provides for a $7,500 tax break but only for first-time home buyers.
Isakson's office said the proposal would cost the government an estimated $19 billion.
The provision was the second tax cut approved in as many days targeted to individual industries. On Tuesday, the Senate voted to give a break to consumers who buy new cars.
The House approved its own version of the bill last week.

Sphere: Related Content

2 comments:

VH said...

Walter E. Williams agrees with your assessment on the stimulus package: It will end up being not much of anything except more public debt. Liberals and progressives have accused conservatives and Republicans of using a crisis to push their legislation through yet we now see Mr. Obama and the Democrats doing the very same thing. "Vote with us or the country is sunk," is their masterful ploy to get Republicans to vote for their Christmas tree laden package. Republicans should not vote for this package so that when it fails (and it will), Democrats own it alone.

The Historian said...

VH-

It appears as if Republicans will take your advice and let the Dems own this massive, Trojan horse, give away. It will do little to stimulate since it is by and large a targeted, partisan spending package that burdens tax payers for generations.

Great comment, thanks.